Big Sprinkler
Our sponsors

Advertise Here:
This form does not yet contain any fields.
    « Sorting wheat from chaff when seeking nutritional advice | Main | Manual shows IRS views horse and cattle industries with suspicion By John Alan Cohan, Esq. »
    Thursday
    Nov072013

    Tax Court Case considers how horse businesses are run in allowing loss deduction

    By John Alan Cohan, Attorney at Law

         In the Tax Court case, Richard H. Daley, T.C. Memo l996-259, an Arizona surgeon was denied deductions with respect to his cutting horse activity.  The Tax Court, which in recent years has become more and more hard-nosed, concluded that the activity was not conducted for profit within the relevant IRS Regulations. 

         A number of facts worked against Dr. Daley: (l) He entered the activity without the aid of a written market study; (2) the evidence suggested that his motive for entering the activity was recreational; (3) he never relied on a formal profit or business plan; (4) in managing the activity he used a ledger to record various transactions and events, and had a separate “drop” file for each horse--but failed to maintain them in a completely accurate manner;  (5) while he claimed to have devoted l0-l2 hours per week to the horse activity, he was unable to substantiate this to the Court’s satisfaction.

         The Court suggested there should have been “a formal market study prior to undertaking his horse activity.”  Under this Court’s criteria, very few horse owners would pass muster.  The opinion suggests that taxpayers in the horse industry are going to have to engage in a lot more of formalities  insofar as documenting how they started the activity. 

    If you have a significant amount of losses you have a good chance of eventually being audited; it is therefore very important to document your compliance with IRS Regulations pertaining to the hobby loss rule. 

    Dr. Daley was unable to show that the he consulted with  industry experts prior to entering the activity.  He testified that he had such consultations, but the judge found his testimony lacking in credibility.  There was no documentation to back him up. This case therefore amplifies the importance of establishing groundwork documentary evidence and preserving it. 

    It is important to maintain inventory records on each animal, including parentage, birth date, birth weight, and registration information.  There should be a chart of horses owned and sold, with details.  It is important to keep separate files on each horse.

    If you are audited, it is important to immediately obtain legal assistance.  Evidence of your businesslike purpose should be presented to the auditor in the most favorable light.  Your business plan should be set forth in a clear and concise manner. How you eventually expect to make a profit should be made clear.  If losses are due to unforeseen circumstances or setbacks, including disease or fluctuating market prices, you should maintain  documentary evidence to prove these facts.  The IRS also wants to see evidence that you keep abreast of industry practices and that you investigate the possibility of changing or abandoning current methods of operation in an effort to mitigate losses.

    In many cases, taxpayers have convinced the Tax Court that their horse activity is a business rather than a hobby despite over two decades of losses.  In those cases the taxpayers had good evidence showing the businesslike manner in which they operated their venture.  The horse owners who come through well in audits usually have a working knowledge about genetic principles and other elements of animal husbandry.  They usually strive to raise high quality animals, and have a plan on how to market them or otherwise make a profit. 

     

      [John Alan Cohan is a lawyer who has served the horse, livestock and farming industries since l98l.  He serves can be reached by telephone at (3l0) 278-0203 or via e-mail at JohnAlanCohan@aol.com.  His website is www.johnalancohan.com.]

    References (11)

    References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
    • Response
      Response: 压瓦机
      2-6米液压剪æ�¿æœºé€‚用于电 网站主页 器开关柜ã€�文件柜ã€�厨房用具ã€�汽车 å…¬å�¸ç®€ä»‹ 尾箱装璜等产å“�çš„æ�¿æ–™æŠ˜å¼¯å·¥åº�,也å�¯å¯¹ç¢³é’¢æ�¿ã€�ä¸�锈钢æ�¿ã€�é“�æ�¿ã€�é“œæ�¿ç­‰è¿›è¡Œå‰ªåˆ‡ã€‚首先开动剪æ�¿æœºæœºå™¨ä½œç©ºè½¬è‹¥å¹²å¾ªçŽ¯ 产å“�展示 ,确ä
    • Response
      Response: invertir en bolsa
      Tax Court Case considers how horse businesses are run in allowing loss deduction - Expert Advice for your equine stable business - Equine Stable Business News
    • Response
      Tax Court Case considers how horse businesses are run in allowing loss deduction - Expert Advice for your equine stable business - Equine Stable Business News
    • Response
      Response: hechizos de amor
      Tax Court Case considers how horse businesses are run in allowing loss deduction - Expert Advice for your equine stable business - Equine Stable Business News
    • Response
      Response: Universal tv base
      Tax Court Case considers how horse businesses are run in allowing loss deduction - Expert Advice for your equine stable business - Equine Stable Business News
    • Response
      Response: Shardbook.It
      Tax Court Case considers how horse businesses are run in allowing loss deduction - Expert Advice for your equine stable business - Equine Stable Business News
    • Response
      Tax Court Case considers how horse businesses are run in allowing loss deduction - Expert Advice for your equine stable business - Equine Stable Business News
    • Response
      The education is the step by step process. Its starts from the basic information, annually after the exams the students promote into next class that have more advance knowledge than to previous curriculum.
    • Response
      Response: Malaysia taxation
      And multiply 6 taxi for sure, 45 if jersey tax income.
    • Response
      The supposition recommends that citizens in the steed business are going to need to participate in a great deal a greater amount of customs seeing that recording how they began the action.
    • Response

    Reader Comments (1)

    Horse business can be high-profitable. Although people cannot do what they don't like to do , thus it is a horse hobby too. People who are involved in this business should be well-educated and use writing services to write reviews on their work.

    March 31, 2015 | Unregistered Commenterresumes planet

    PostPost a New Comment

    Enter your information below to add a new comment.

    My response is on my own website »
    Author Email (optional):
    Author URL (optional):
    Post:
     
    Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>